Consent is not the standard for what is acceptable and what is wrong and sinful.

The word “sin” almost feels like a bad word in our society today. In a secular culture that values personal autonomy so highly, for anyone to tell someone else what is right or wrong can be seen as a violation of their personal freedom, especially if their choices aren't hurting anyone else.

This leads to sayings like “We shouldn’t care what two (or more) people decide to do behind closed doors,” “If you don’t like something, just don’t do it,” and “Live your truth.” And certainly no one has the right to tell anyone else that they are sinning.

This emphasis on personal freedom has made consent an increasingly common standard for determining what is acceptable. The idea is that as long as everyone (be it one person or multiple people) consents to an activity or behavior, it is morally acceptable for them to participate. And if you don’t like it, just don’t do it yourself.

Taken to its logical conclusion, this would mean any consensual sexual activity is therefore okay, no matter how deviant or destructive. Any intake of substances is okay as long as the person wants to take it. You can’t say that the meteoric rise of sports gambling that is ruining many men’s lives is morally wrong because they consented to gamble everything away. As long as a doctor and a minor consent to irreversibly cutting up a perfectly healthy body because said minor thinks they have the wrong body, you can’t argue it’s wrong to do. If consent alone determines morality, there is little room to argue that someone is doing something wrong simply because of the nature of the action itself.

But consent is not a biblical definition or qualification for whether something is sinful in the Bible. Of course, one does not have to care what the Bible says, but what you cannot do is define sin by the definition of consent. Why? Because sin is any thought, desire, attitude, action, or failure to act that goes against God's character and commands. Take God out of the picture, and sin must go with him.

This is why using consent as a placeholder for sin is not possible. Nowhere in Scripture can you make the case that so long as people consent, that which is morally wrong is now morally right.

Consent cannot make anything that is sin not sinful. You can consent to sexual sin. You can consent to worshipping a false god. You can consent to self-mutilation. You can consent to any sort of behavior, but it does not make that action or behavior good.

And while consent does not make bad things good, lack of consent can make things bad. To be preyed upon or to be acted against in a negative way against your will is to be sinned against. I am not arguing here that consent doesn’t matter, but simply that it is not a marker for whether or not something is sinful.

Instead, we see in 1 John 3:4 that “Everyone who commits sin practices lawlessness; and sin is lawlessness." Consenting to lawlessness does not make it any less sinful.

At the end of the book of Judges, after reading a number of heartbreaking stories of evil and wickedness, the book ends with this haunting phrase, "In those days there was no king in Israel; everyone did whatever seemed right to him." (21:25). The implication is that everyone doing whatever seems right to them is not good; it leads to tragic circumstances.

Finally, Proverbs 14:12 tells us, "There is a way that seems right to a person, but its end is the way to death." Again, just because we want to do something, that does not automatically mean that it is right. To be sure, there are many things we want to do that are good, but desirability is not the litmus test for whether something is moral or not. We can consent to many things that bring pain and harm.

So beware of treating consent as a proxy for what is acceptable to God and what is not. Consent may be the trendy expression of the day, but it is always better to follow God’s eternal wisdom.

More resources to help find clarity in the Bible 🙌

  • 📱Get more free content from me to help you bring clarity to the Bible on X/Twitter and Instagram.

  • 📧 Check out my weekly Tuesday email, Bible Made Simple, where I give short, applicable explanations and teachings straight from God’s Word.

  • 📖 Get my Ephesians Devotional Study to help you better understand and apply the book of Ephesians to your life.

Login or Subscribe to participate